At Thought Leaders Business School, we spend a lot of time helping people decide which games they’re going to play.
Listen to the blog here.
Serious people are not on social. Well, that’s probably overstating it, but there’s something in the provocation worth exploring. The problem with social media is that it’s very easy to find yourself playing a game that has very little to do with the practice you’re trying to build. You start worrying about posting frequency, engagement rates, algorithm changes and whether your videos should be recorded directly inside Instagram. Before long, the algorithm is wagging your practice. You’re making decisions about your business based on what a technology platform wants you to do, rather than what makes sense for the reputation you’re trying to build.
At Thought Leaders Business School, we spend a lot of time helping people decide which games they’re going to play. There’s the IP development game, where you turn your thinking into valuable intellectual property. There’s the revenue game, where you learn to commercialise that thinking. And there’s the generosity game, where you consistently share useful ideas with the people you want to serve. These are games worth getting good at. But there are also three games I think you should be very careful about playing.
The first is the social media game.
There’s a difference between using social media and playing the social media game. The game suggests that the path to success involves becoming an influencer, mastering the algorithm and generating an ever-increasing amount of content to keep yourself visible. There’s nothing inherently wrong with any of that, but I wonder whether it’s the right ambition for someone building a thought leadership practice.
Your job is to build reputational capital. Think about what would happen if 15 key people of influence knew your work well enough to recommend you. Imagine having 150 people who would return your call if you left them a voicemail. Then imagine 1,500 people who regularly open and read your newsletter because they genuinely value your thinking. That’s a substantial commercial asset. And for many thought leaders, it would be worth considerably more than hundreds of social media posts generating thousands of impressions from people who have very little interest in buying what you do.
The distinction I like to make is that you want to sell like a surgeon rather than a social media maven. A surgeon doesn’t need to be famous to have a thriving practice. They need to be known, trusted and recommended by the right people. Their reputation precedes the commercial conversation. That’s a much more useful model for most of the experts we work with.
The second is the proposal game.
I’ve written about this before because I think it’s one of the most common commercial mistakes experts make. Someone expresses interest in your work and before you’ve really explored what they need, what they’re prepared to invest or what a successful engagement might look like, you offer to send them a proposal. It feels productive. It feels professional. And it gives everyone a convenient way to avoid having the commercial conversation that actually matters.
I’m not suggesting you stop writing proposals. In many organisations they’re a necessary part of procurement, and sometimes they’re simply the appropriate way to document an agreement. What I’m suggesting is that the proposal should contain no surprises. By the time you write it, you should already know the scope, the outcomes, the investment, the timing and the decision process. These things should have been explored and agreed in conversation.
A proposal is a useful record of a commercial commitment. It’s a very poor substitute for creating one.
The next time someone asks you to send a proposal, pay attention to what happens inside you. Are you clear about what you’re proposing because you’ve had the necessary conversations? Or are you hoping that the document will somehow fill in the gaps, make the case and persuade the client on your behalf? If it’s the latter, there’s probably another conversation you need to have before opening your laptop.
The third is the Field of Dreams game.
This is the belief that if you build something good enough, people will eventually find their way to you. Do great work, write a brilliant book, develop some extraordinary IP, deliver a wonderful keynote and somehow the market will notice. It’s an attractive idea, particularly for experts who would rather spend their time developing their craft than having commercial conversations.
Unfortunately, the world doesn’t work quite like that. Good work matters enormously, but it doesn’t automatically create demand. You have to keep inviting people into your world. You need to create opportunities for people to experience your thinking, understand your value and consider working with you. Sometimes that means making an explicit invitation. Sometimes it means asking for the business. And sometimes it means being willing to put a relationship or an opportunity at risk by moving beyond a pleasant conversation into a commercial one.
This doesn’t require you to become a hustler. It requires you to develop a rhythm of invitation.
One of the practices we encourage is sending a useful newsletter every week or two to a growing audience. This is your regular generosity activity. You’re sharing ideas, building familiarity and giving people a reason to stay connected with your thinking. Alongside that, every season you should have a specific commercial campaign directed towards a relevant group within your database.
Imagine you have 1,500 people who regularly read your newsletter. Within that group there might be 60 learning and development professionals working inside organisations. You’ve developed a facilitation skills workshop that would be valuable to them. Rather than sending a generic sales message to all 1,500 people, you create a targeted campaign for those 60 professionals. You explain the workshop, why it matters, what it helps people do and how they might engage you to deliver it. You follow up with the people who express interest and have the appropriate commercial conversations.
That’s what marketing can look like in a thought leadership practice. A regular rhythm of generosity supported by specific, relevant invitations. Your newsletter builds reputational capital and your campaigns create commercial opportunities. The two activities work together, and neither requires you to spend your life chasing an algorithm.
I think there’s a larger point here about the kind of practice you’re choosing to build. It’s remarkably easy to become busy playing games that other people have decided are important. Social media platforms want your attention and your content. Procurement processes encourage you to compete through documents. And the Field of Dreams fantasy gives you permission to keep working on your ideas without ever having to risk asking someone to buy them.
The alternative is to become much more deliberate about where you invest your energy. Build a reputation with people who matter to your work. Have the conversations that create genuine commercial commitments. And keep giving people a reason to engage with you through a consistent rhythm of generosity and invitation.
There are plenty of games worth playing when you’re building a thought leadership practice. Knowing which ones to avoid might be just as important as knowing which ones to master.
.png?width=300&height=180&name=Matt%20Church%20SIGNATURE%20UNDERLINE%20BLACK%20transparent%20bgrnd%20(1).png)